Thursday, 13 December 2012

Review: 'A History of Myanmar Since Ancient Times', by Michael and Maitrii Aung-Thwin

Although I am relatively new to Burmese history and historiography, I like to think I know a fair amount about southeast Asia as a whole.  As such, I feel confident enough to take a break from epistemology to review the book I've just been reading, A History of Myanmar Since Ancient Times, by historians Michael Aung-Thwin and Maitrii Aung-Thwin (2012, London: Reaktion Books).  The book deals with the history of Myanmar from 40,000 BCE to the present in a little under three hundred pages, but I am only concerned with the first 140 pages or so - from the arrival of H. erectus to the declines of Ava (Inwa) and Pegu in the early sixteenth century (while I find the recent history of Myanmar interesting, my purpose in reading the book was to gain an understanding of prehistoric and ancient times).


The first point to make is that the writing is clear but combative, even pugnacious (as another reviewer, Ian Brown from SOAS, has pointed out).  The authors want to correct errors in the traditional account of Myanmar and don't mince their words doing it, which is quite refreshing.  As this book is about the role of the state in Myanmar - the only possible route when enquiring into the early history of the region given the nature of the evidence, I might add - the authors are attempting to counter-act Scott's Art of Not Being Governed, which focuses on the hill tribes.  On the other hand, this book was written by historians, and it shows.  While other works on prehistory and ancient history draw on archaeological research, it is evident that the Aung-Thwins are more conversant with historical schools and ideas.  As this is the only recent book to attempt to cover the span of human life in the country in anything like a comprehensive manner, it's somewhat disappointing to see this historical focus, as it means that the early chapters, on prehistory and the early historic period - the ones I am most interested in - are stilted, short, and relatively insubstantial.

This would not make a great introduction to Myanmar to anyone who knows nothing about southeast Asia.  The Cholas, Srivijaya, Angkor, Champa, and Nanzhao are all referenced with little explanation, which could easily be confusing if you aren't aware of them beforehand.  On top of this, the writing, while perfectly clear to those experienced in academic writing, is a bit convoluted for a popular audience.  One of my pet peeves is also lamentably present: the use of Wade-Giles transliteration for Chinese ('Nanchao' for Nanzhao, for instance).  This is a bit like using the terms Hindoo and Mohametan, and it should stop.  It isn't appropriate in a work of 2012, and it just looks silly.

There are also a few errors or omissions in the early sections.  While archaeology in Myanmar is certainly under-developed, there is very little point in pretending that the book is comprehensive when it deals with all of the developments from the arrival of H. erectus through to the origins of urbanism in Myanmar in nine pages.  This puts the succeeding discussion of urbanisation on an uneven footing; there is little explanation provided in the book about why the bronze- and iron-working people of Upper Myanmar ended up building and living in cities, nor, even, any explanation of how bronze and iron ended up being worked in southeast Asia in the first place.  Compare this to the excellent discussions of Angkor's rise, on the back of an understanding of Neolithic and Iron Age southeast Asia, in Charles Higham's and Michael Coe's works.  I appreciate that this is in part due to the nature of the archaeological evidence in under-funded Myanmar, but I find it hard to believe that even this small amount of evidence can be properly summed up in nine pages of text.  India's role in southeast Asia is also given a very limited place in this account, which is unfortunate - the authors are clearly seeking to emphasise the indigenous nature of Myanma civilisation, but this is difficult to do if you avoid a serious discussion of how Indian influence and Buddhism entered Myanmar in the first place.

Moreover, the question of whether southeast Asians descend from H. erectus is left open, but the answer is, of course, known: Homo sapiens sapiens evolved primarily in Africa, moving to other parts of the world after H. erectus, and all human populations descend from a single recent African H. sapiens sapiens population rather than from dispersed H. erectus populations.  This is presented as a controversy in the Aung-Thwins' book when it is nothing of the sort.  And what is more, to be unaware that the evidence from Spirit Cave, once claimed (by Wilhelm Solheim) to show proof of the earliest known agriculture in the world, is now considered to be totally wrong and poorly interpreted is a sin for someone writing a general history of any part of southeast Asia (this, too, is presented as a controversy, when it is anything but).

There is also some confusion in the book about scripts.  I'm not sure if this reflects the authors' own level of knowledge or whether it was felt necessary to dumb down discussion of how writing arrived in Myanmar, but the script that entered southeast Asia is erroneously called 'Sanskrit', which is the name of a language, not a script (the script that influenced southeast Asian writing most was, of course, Pallava, a south Indian script derived from Brahmi via Tamil Brahmi, and ultimately from some unknown North Semitic source).  There is also little about the nature of Myanma epigraphy.  As epigraphic evidence is foremost in understanding ancient southeast Asia, this is a major omission, and - as a relative neophyte - I am left unsure about what evidence there is of the Pyu, Pali, and Sanskrit languages in Myanmar, let alone Old and Middle Burmese.  A few examples of inscriptions - transliterations and translations** - would have been nice.

There are good things about the book.  For instance, the focus on clearing up misconceptions in Myanma historiography was very helpful, especially as it removed a couple of problems I was having with the so-called 'Pyu' era (the label is rejected by the Aung-Thwins in favour of, simply, 'The Urban Period', c.200 BCE - 900 CE).  I also liked the emphasis on the state, which, partly due to the work of James Scott, has not received its fair share of attention.  While it is quite easy to find books on ancient Thai kingdoms, Angkor, and even Champa, there are very few on Pagan, Ava, and Pegu, and the most recent work touching on Myanmar to receive popular and academic acclaim focused primarily on non-state peoples (Scott's aforementioned book).  This only leads academic attention away from southeast Asia as a source of civilisation and the state, meaning that evidence from the region relevant to academic dissections of the origins of social inequality and urbanisation are ignored or seen as derivative of Indian influence.

This is a reasonable general survey, but it's unclear who its market is; laymen won't know enough about other southeast Asian states to make reading this history worthwhile, and the theoretical focus - 'agency' and the Annales School, &c. - isn't going to earn it any favours in the popular market.  Other southeast Asianists are unlikely to benefit from the superficial covering of Myanma prehistory, and the use of archaic transliterations limits its use by Sinologists, amongst others.

This is also quite a conversative work.  While I approve of the emphasis on the state, in that it provides a clear window into the past, it seems to me that at least some of the emphasis on cultural continuity and the 'golden age' of Pagan - depicted a little too beneficently, if you ask me - derives from a strain of patriotism or common feeling for Myanmar's people and culture, which isn't exactly what I was looking for (I like to know facts, not nationalistic narratives).  Much of the discussion of Ava - once thought to be a 'dark age' in Myanmar's history - seemed swayed by the desire to portray it in a positive, nationalistic, light, and the rejection of major Shan and Mon influence on Myanmar's subsequent development seemed like it carried a political edge.  (To see these tensions in practice, take a look at the comments on this video - clearly Myanmar nationalism and the various ethnic identities have a rather fraught relationship.)

Nevertheless, this is really the only general survey out there, and unless you want to piece together your own history of Myanmar from the short range of academic articles and old books out there, then this is the place to go for Myanmar's history.  It is pacy, easy reading if you don't mind the academic style, and the information is important - Pagan was about as big an influence in Asian history as Angkor and is much less known due to political circumstance.  The maps are quite good, and I have no doubt that the history of the British presence in Myanmar ('Burma') and the post-independence era is of high quality (and that is, truth be told, probably what most people reading the book really want).

Again, I am relatively new to the history of Myanmar, and I may be barking up the wrong tree or stomping all over well-worn academic controversies without being aware of it.

* The issue of 'Burma' vs. 'Myanmar' is discussed in an introductory note; neither Burma nor Myanmar is an entirely appropriate name, because 'Burma' (from Bama) is an Anglicism and 'Myanmar', while indigenous, is actually derived from an adjective rather than a noun.  It should be called Myanma Pyay, but it seems unlikely that anyone will ever adopt this as the name outside of Myanma Pyay itself.

** Examples of the original script would be even better, but those only seem to crop up in nineteenth century tomes and recent archaeological articles, not attempts at comprehensive histories.  Pallava gets my vote for 'world's most beautiful script', by the way (just don't confuse it with Grantha, as many people seem to, and as that wiki article does).

20 comments:

  1. A wonderful review and critique! Over the last year, I've been piecing together exactly what you describe in your penultimate paragraph (a piecemeal history of Myanmar gathered from broader books about S.E. Asia and the random Myanmar-focused historical works available). I live in Laos, where it's difficult to access books, and I was thrilled to get my hands on a copy of the Aung-Thwins' work this winter.

    I agree with most of your points, and I don't think you've stepped on any well-worn controversies (as far as my armchair academics' scope will allow me to see, anyway). The Aung-Thwins' voice is pretty singular in the current discourse on Myanmar. As Thant Myint-U (the author of the River of Lost Footsteps, probably the reigning champion of popular histories of Myanmar) points out, most public discussion of Myanmar is weirdly ahistorical. I appreciate Michael and Maitrii Aung-Thwin for their willingness to take a strong position on the history of Myanmar, because nobody else is offering it: now, at least, people like us have a text to read and agree or argue with.

    Still, there are moments in "A History of Myanmar" that make me roll my eyes. You articulate the oddities of their stance well: It's a kind of patriotism, or at least nationalism. I have wondered frequently while reading this book whether or not they're just trying to please some friends in Naypyidaw who hold the keys to lucrative archives. The laudatory tone with which they address Pagan didn't surprise me, but I was a little bewildered by the praise they heap on the Ava-Pegu period. In some respects, they seem to fetishize the militaristic rulers of those two nation/city-states in a way that eerily echoes the fascination of the current Myanmar military.

    Anyway, I appreciate their continued resistance to the "good-evil struggle" paradigm, even if I wish they were a bit more critical of the military (has the Burmese military really ever "restored order," as they state in the final chapter?). I look forward to the other books that participate in this discussion and the Aung-Thwins' future efforts. Thanks for the review!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Clarifications: by "reigning champion" I mean champion in terms of widespread exposure (in S.E. Asia, I meet heaps of people who've read Myint-U's work), and by "people like us" I mean people interested in the history of Myanmar.

      Delete
    2. I've been re-reading a bit of the Aung-Thwin book in writing a piece of my own, and while I approve of some of the arguments - say, about the rise of urbanisation in Lower Myanmar - I find some of them bizarre. For instance, the definitive arrival of Mranma people into Myanmar seems to have occurred with the Nanzhao invasion in the early 9th century. That's the earliest reference to people who later became Burmese. But the Aung-Thwins claim that Mranma people were probably in Myanmar before this, making up a key component of the Pyu city-states. I don't think this is justified by any evidence and seems to be predicated on the notion that the Mranma have to be indigenous. That certainly made my eyes roll!

      Delete
  2. Do you need a Loan?
    Are you looking for Finance?
    Are you looking for a Loan to enlarge your business?
    I think you have come to the right place.
    We offer Loans at low interest rate.
    Interested people should please contact us on
    For immediate response to your application, Kindly
    reply to this emails below only
    easyloanoffer1@gmail.com

    LOAN APPLICATION INFORMATION FORM
    First name:
    Middle name:
    Date of birth (yyyy-mm-dd):
    Gender:
    Marital status:
    Total Amount Needed:
    Time Duration:
    Address:
    City:
    State/province:
    Zip/postal code:
    Country:
    Phone:
    Email ID.....
    Mobile/cellular:
    Monthly Income:
    Occupation:
    Which sites did you know about us.....
    easyloanoffer1@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete
  3. Do you need a Loan?
    Are you looking for Finance?
    Are you looking for a Loan to enlarge your business?
    I think you have come to the right place.
    We offer Loans at low interest rate.
    Interested people should please contact us on
    For immediate response to your application, Kindly
    reply to this emails below only
    easyloanoffer1@gmail.com

    LOAN APPLICATION INFORMATION FORM
    First name:
    Middle name:
    Date of birth (yyyy-mm-dd):
    Gender:
    Marital status:
    Total Amount Needed:
    Time Duration:
    Address:
    City:
    State/province:
    Zip/postal code:
    Country:
    Phone:
    Email ID.....
    Mobile/cellular:
    Monthly Income:
    Occupation:
    Which sites did you know about us.....
    easyloanoffer1@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete
  4. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hello Everybody,
    My name is Mrs Sharon Sim. I live in Singapore and i am a happy woman today? and i told my self that any lender that rescue my family from our poor situation, i will refer any person that is looking for loan to him, he gave me happiness to me and my family, i was in need of a loan of S$250,000.00 to start my life all over as i am a single mother with 3 kids I met this honest and GOD fearing man loan lender that help me with a loan of S$250,000.00 SG. Dollar, he is a GOD fearing man, if you are in need of loan and you will pay back the loan please contact him tell him that is Mrs Sharon, that refer you to him. contact Dr Purva Pius,via email:(urgentloan22@gmail.com) Thank you.

    BORROWERS APPLICATION DETAILS


    1. Name Of Applicant in Full:……..
    2. Telephone Numbers:……….
    3. Address and Location:…….
    4. Amount in request………..
    5. Repayment Period:………..
    6. Purpose Of Loan………….
    7. country…………………
    8. phone…………………..
    9. occupation………………
    10.age/sex…………………
    11.Monthly Income…………..
    12.Email……………..

    Regards.
    Managements
    Email Kindly Contact: urgentloan22@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete
  6. Top of the day to you i want to bring to your notice that we offer a free and secure loan transaction which can be deliver to you within the next 48 hours of application from the stable of Kenneth Beare Loan Firm.We offer loan out at a very low rate 3% if you are interested to have a legitimate transaction then you have arrive at the right source. osmanmoneyfinance@gmail.com

    LOAN APPLICATION FORM
    Name:
    Sex:
    Address:
    Occupation:
    State:
    Country:
    Phone Number:
    Loan Duration:
    Loan Needed:
    Have you applied before?:
    Email us osmanmoneyfinance@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete
  7. Hello Everybody,
    My name is Mrs Sharon Sim. I live in Singapore and i am a happy woman today? and i told my self that any lender that rescue my family from our poor situation, i will refer any person that is looking for loan to him, he gave me happiness to me and my family, i was in need of a loan of S$250,000.00 to start my life all over as i am a single mother with 3 kids I met this honest and GOD fearing man loan lender that help me with a loan of S$250,000.00 SG. Dollar, he is a GOD fearing man, if you are in need of loan and you will pay back the loan please contact him tell him that is Mrs Sharon, that refer you to him. contact Dr Purva Pius,via email:(urgentloan22@gmail.com) Thank you.

    BORROWERS APPLICATION DETAILS


    1. Name Of Applicant in Full:……..
    2. Telephone Numbers:……….
    3. Address and Location:…….
    4. Amount in request………..
    5. Repayment Period:………..
    6. Purpose Of Loan………….
    7. country…………………
    8. phone…………………..
    9. occupation………………
    10.age/sex…………………
    11.Monthly Income…………..
    12.Email……………..

    Regards.
    Managements
    Email Kindly Contact: urgentloan22@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete
  8. NEED LOAN URGENT, CONTACT US TODAY FOR MORE DETAILS.
    Are you looking for a loan to clear off your dept and start up your own Business? have you being going all over yet not able to get a legit loan Company that will loan you? Here is your final solution, We can give you any amount you need provided you are going to pay back within the period of time given without any problem. Apply now and contact us for more details via email below. Email: trivagofinancialhome.in@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete
  9. Good day:
    Do you need an urgent loan to solve your financial needs, we offer ranging from $ 5,000.00 to $ 10,000,000.00 loan Max, we are reliable, efficient, fast and dynamic, with 100% Guaranteed We also gives u credit to the (euro, pounds and dollars.) The interest rate applicable to all payday loans (3%), if you are interested get back to us via [trivagofinancialhome.in@gmail.com) with the

    information below:
    Your full name:
    Country:
    Amount of loan
    Address:
    Duration:
    Age:
    Sex:
    Occupation:
    Phone number:

    Once we are in receipt of this information,You will be sent the company loan terms and condition immediately.Be assured that your loan application will be handled with privacy and in a professional manner and you will receive a prompt answer to your request.
    trivagofinancialhome.in@gmail.com
    Best Regards,
    Mr. Hussein Mohammed

    ReplyDelete
  10. Do you need Finance?
    Are you looking for Finance?
    Are you looking for a money to enlarge your business?
    We help individuals and companies to obtain loan for business
    expanding and to setup a new business ranging any amount. Get a loan at affordable interest rate of 3%, Do you need this cash/loan for business and to clear your bills? Then send us an email now for more information contact us now via Email:maxcreditfinance@googlemail.com

    ReplyDelete

  11. We offer fresh cut bank instrument for lease, such as BG, SBLC,Lease and Purchase Instruments can be obtained at minimal expense to the borrower compared to other banking options. This offer is opened to both individuals and corporate bodies.

    DESCRIPTION OF INSTRUMENTS

    1. Instrument: Funds backed Bank Guarantee(BG) ICC-600
    2. Currency : USD/EURO
    3. Age of Issue: Fresh Cut
    4. Term: One year and One day
    5. Contract Amount: United State Dollars/Euros (Buyers Face Value)
    6. Price : Buy:32%+1, Lease: 4%+2
    7. Subsequent tranches: To be mutually agreed between both parties
    8. Issuing Bank: Top RATED world banks like HSBC, Barclays, ING Dutch Bank, Llyods e.t.c
    9. Delivery Term: Pre advise MT199 or MT799 first. Followed By SWIFT MT760
    10. Payment Term: MT799 & Settlement via MT103
    11. Hard Copy: By Bank Bonded Courier


    Interested Agents,Brokers, Investors and Individual proposing international project funding should contact us for directives.We will be glad to share our working procedures with you upon request

    Name:Ardan Clooney
    Email:brandfinance33@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete

  12. We are a Finance Industry Company professionals with over 15 Years Experience and a focus on providing Bank Guarantee and Standby Letter of Credit from some of the World Top 25 Prime Banks primarily from Barclays, Deutsche Bank, HSBC,Credit Suisse e.t.c.

    FEATURES:
    Amounts from $1 million to 5 Billion+
    Euro’s or US Dollars
    Great Attorney Trust Account Protection
    Delivered via MT760, MT799 and MT103 Swift with Full Bank Responsibility
    Brokers Always Protected

    Purchase Instrument of BG/SBLC : 32%+2% Min Face Value cut = EUR/USD 1M-5B
    Lease Instrument of BG/SBLC : 4%+2% Min Face Value cut = EUR/USD 1M-5B

    Interested Agents/Brokers, Investors and Individual proposing international project funding should contact us for directives.We will be glad to share our working procedures with you upon request.


    We Facilitate Bank instruments SBLC for Lease and Purchase. Whether you are a new startup, medium or large establishment that needs a financial solution to fund/get your project off the ground or business looking for extra capital to expand your operation,our company renders credible and trusted bank guarantee provider who are willing to fund and give financing solutions that suits your specific business needs.

    We help you secure and issue sblc and bank guarantee for your trade, projects and investment from top AA rated world Banks like HSBC, Barclays, Dutch Ing Bank, Llyods e.t.c because that’s the best and safest strategy for our clients.e.t.c

    DESCRIPTION OF INSTRUMENTS

    1. Instrument: Funds backed Bank Guarantee(BG) ICC-600
    2. Currency : USD/EURO
    3. Age of Issue: Fresh Cut
    4. Term: One year and One day
    5. Contract Amount: United State Dollars/Euros (Buyers Face Value)
    6. Price : Buy:32%+1, Lease: 4%+2
    7. Subsequent tranches: To be mutually agreed between both parties
    8. Issuing Bank: Top RATED world banks like HSBC, Barclays, ING Dutch Bank, Llyods e.t.c
    9. Delivery Term: Pre advise MT199 or MT799 first. Followed By SWIFT MT760
    10. Payment Term: MT799 & Settlement via MT103
    11. Hard Copy: By Bank Bonded Courier


    Interested Agents,Brokers, Investors and Individual proposing international project funding should contact us for directives.We will be glad to share our working procedures with you upon request.



    Name:Richardson McAnthony
    Contact Mail : intertekfinance@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete
  13. Good day:
    Do you need an urgent loan to solve your financial needs, we offer
    ranging from $ 5,000.00 to $ 10,000,000.00 loan Max, we are reliable,
    efficient, fast and dynamic, with 100% Guaranteed We also gives u credit
    to the (euro, pounds and dollars.) The interest rate applicable to all
    payday loans (2%), if you are interested get back to us via
    ibrahimfunds6@gmail.com) with the information below:

    ReplyDelete
  14. Do you need Finance?
    Are you looking for Finance?
    Are you looking for a money to enlarge your business?
    We help individuals and companies to obtain loan for business
    expanding and to setup a new business ranging any amount. Get a loan at affordable interest rate of 3%, Do you need this cash/loan for business and to clear your bills? Then send us an email now for more information contact us now via Email:maxcreditfinance@googlemail.com

    ReplyDelete
  15. We offer worldwide loan at very low interest rates of 2% we offer mortage, company, business loan, personal loan,
    housing, the purchase of land and many more. Loan offer with the most genuine and honest business and personal loans low interest rate of 2% no collateral required process takes just 2/3 Days. contact us now
    bullsindia182@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete
  16. Am a government approve private loan lender,fully registered and licensed,i give out the best loan to my client at a very convenient rate.The interest rate of this loan is 3%. I give out loan to public and private individuals.For more information contact us, for Personal loan, Business loan, Home Loans, etc,we got you covered.
    Please,only serious and genuine people should apply,no matter your financial score,just a Valid ID,bank detail and you will be approved a loan. If you are a serious and ambitious person and wishes to apply for a loan contact us today at Email: maxcreditfinance@googlemail.com

    ReplyDelete
  17. GREEN FINANCE LOAN CENTER
    HEAD OFFICE--25 Osborn Street, London England
    EMAIL ADDRESS -- {greenfinancecenter@gmail.com}
    ------------------------------------------------

    Welcome to GREEN FINANCE LOAN CENTER,
    We give out loans from the range of $9,000 to $900,000,000
    at 2% interest rate

    we provide all kind of loans below --

    * Project Loans
    * Personal Loans
    * Debt consolidation loans
    * Car Loans
    * Business Loans
    * Education Loans
    * Mortgage Loans
    * Refinancing Loans
    * Home Loans

    Kindly apply by providing us with the details below-

    NAME ......
    COUNTRY......
    AMOUNT OF LOAN NEEDED .....
    PHONE NUMBER ......
    PURPOSE OF LOAN ....

    Email address --{greenfinancecenter@gmail.com}

    REGARDS
    CHARLENE FREDERICK
    {greenfinancecenter@gmail.com}
    www.greenfinanceservices.webs.com
    GREEN FINANCE LOAN CENTER

    ReplyDelete
  18. GREEN FINANCE LOAN CENTER
    HEAD OFFICE--25 Osborn Street, London England
    EMAIL ADDRESS -- {greenfinancecenter@gmail.com}
    ------------------------------------------------

    Welcome to GREEN FINANCE LOAN CENTER,
    We give out loans from the range of $9,000 to $900,000,000
    at 2% interest rate

    we provide all kind of loans below --

    * Project Loans
    * Personal Loans
    * Debt consolidation loans
    * Car Loans
    * Business Loans
    * Education Loans
    * Mortgage Loans
    * Refinancing Loans
    * Home Loans

    Kindly apply by providing us with the details below-

    NAME ......
    COUNTRY......
    AMOUNT OF LOAN NEEDED .....
    PHONE NUMBER ......
    PURPOSE OF LOAN ....

    Email address --{greenfinancecenter@gmail.com}

    REGARDS
    CHARLENE FREDERICK
    {greenfinancecenter@gmail.com}
    www.greenfinanceservices.webs.com
    GREEN FINANCE LOAN CENTER

    ReplyDelete

You can post anonymously if you really want to, but I would appreciate it if you could provide some means of identifying who you are, if only for the purpose of knowing who has written what.